Shyamji, a 55-year-old retired school teacher from Kanpur, walks into his trusted bank branch, his savings from years of hard work tucked away in a fixed deposit. He’s greeted by a smiling relationship manager, someone who knows his family, even asks about his daughter’s wedding. “Sir, yeh ULIP ekdum perfect hai aapke liye,” the manager says, promising high returns, tax benefits, and insurance, all in one shiny package. Shyam, trusting the bank like it’s his own family, signs the papers. Fast forward a few years, and he’s staring at a statement showing returns far lower than promised, trapped in a 15-year lock-in, and realizing the insurance cover is barely enough to cover a hospital bill. His dreams of a comfortable retirement? Shattered. This isn’t just Shyam’s story, it’s the story of millions of Indians caught in the web of Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs), one of the most mis-sold financial products in the country.
What’s Really Going On?
ULIPs, or Unit Linked Insurance Plans, are marketed as the ultimate financial fix, a hybrid product blending life insurance with market-linked investments. A portion of your premium goes toward life cover, while the rest is invested in equity or debt funds, much like mutual funds. Sounds like a dream, right? Insurance aur investment, dono ek saath! But here’s where the plot thickens. Beneath the glossy brochures and smooth-talking agents lies a maze of high commissions, hidden charges, and unmet expectations that’s left countless Indians, from small-town retirees to urban professionals, feeling cheated.
Mis-Selling Tactics: ULIPs are often sold with half-truths, promised as “guaranteed returns” or compared to mutual funds without mentioning the hefty fees or lock-in periods.
High Commissions Driving Sales: Agents and banks earn up to 40% commission in the first year, creating a “push” culture where suitability for the buyer takes a backseat.
Complex Product Structure: With layers of charges, premium allocation, policy administration, mortality, and fund management, ULIPs are tough for the average investor to decode.
Tax Traps: Post-Budget 2021, ULIPs with premiums over ₹2.5 lakh annually are no longer fully tax-exempt, losing their edge over mutual funds.
Low Returns and Inadequate Cover: Returns often hover between 6–8%, even in strong markets, and the insurance component is usually too small to provide meaningful protection.
Targeting the Vulnerable: Senior citizens and financially unsophisticated investors in smaller cities are prime targets, often locked into long-term policies they don’t understand.
Regulatory Gaps: Despite IRDAI mandates for transparency, mis-selling persists due to loopholes in enforcement and commission-driven sales.
Why ULIPs Are a Dangerous Bet
Let’s break it down with some hard-hitting facts. In 2023–24, life insurance companies in India saw a 13.8% year-on-year growth in Annual Premium Equivalent (APE), largely driven by ULIP sales. But here’s the kicker: private insurers, who dominate ULIP sales, prioritize commissions over customer needs. A financial analyst I spoke to (let’s keep it anonymous for now) revealed that banks and agents earn 30–50% of the first-year premium as commission. Compare that to mutual funds, where fees are typically 1–2%. This commission structure creates a perverse incentive to push ULIPs, even when they’re a poor fit.
Take the case of a 63-year-old Mumbai resident, call him Raj, who lost 90% of his ₹5 lakh investment in a Makx Life ULIP bought in 2007. High mortality charges, linked to his age and a high sum assured, ate away his corpus. When the policy was terminated due to a low fund value, he received just ₹50,006. Stories like Raj’s aren’t rare, senior citizens, trusting their banks or agents, are often sold ULIPs with promises of “doubling money” in five years, only to face steep losses if they exit early due to surrender charges.
Then there’s the tax angle. Before 2021, ULIP maturity proceeds were tax-free. Now, if your annual premium across all ULIPs exceeds ₹2.5 lakh, gains are taxed as capital gains, 12.5% for long-term (over 12 months) and up to 20% for short-term. This makes mutual funds, with their transparency and lower costs, a better bet for most investors. Yet, agents rarely mention this change, leaving investors like Shyam blindsided.
Is This Just India’s Problem?
Mis-selling financial products isn’t unique to India, but the scale and systemic nature of ULIP mis-selling stand out. In the UK, the mis-selling of endowment policies in the 1980s and 1990s led to billions in compensation after regulators cracked down. Australia faced a similar scandal with complex investment products pushed by banks, resulting in a 2019 Royal Commission that exposed widespread misconduct. In India, however, regulatory action is slow. The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) issued a 2024 directive mandating clear disclosure of ULIP risks and charges, but enforcement remains weak. Globally, countries with stronger consumer protection, like mandatory cooling-off periods or commission caps, see less mis-selling. India’s high-commission model, coupled with low financial literacy (only 27% of Indians are financially literate), creates a perfect storm.
Here’s where it gets really murky. ULIPs aren’t just expensive, they’re sold to people who can’t afford the long-term commitment. A recent report highlighted how “Highest-NAV-guaranteed” ULIPs, popular between 2008 and 2012, misled investors by promising equity-like returns while heavily investing in fixed-income instruments. When markets soared, policyholders like Mumbai's Dilipbhai got far less than expected because the “highest NAV” wasn’t tied to market highs. These products were banned in 2012, but their legacy lingers, with complaints still flooding insurance ombudsmen.
Another dirty secret? The persistency ratio, the percentage of policies renewed after the first year, is abysmal for ULIPs. Industry data shows that only 50–60% of ULIP policies are renewed after five years, meaning many investors drop out, losing money to surrender charges. This is no accident. Agents target emotionally vulnerable customers, like parents planning for a child’s education or retirees securing their savings, knowing they may not question the fine print.
Your Money, Your Dreams
Bhai, yeh baat dil se dil tak jati hai. We Indians work hard, saving for our kids’ education, our parents’ healthcare, or that dream house. When a bank manager, someone we trust like an elder brother, pushes a ULIP as a “safe bet,” we believe them. But jab sachchai samne aati hai, low returns, high fees, aur long lock-ins, it feels like a betrayal. I’ve spoken to people like Anjali from Pune, who invested ₹1 lakh annually in a ULIP for her son’s future, only to realize the insurance cover was a fraction of what a term plan could offer. “Mujhe laga yeh sab ek hi package mein perfect hai,” she said, her voice heavy with regret. “Par ab lagta hai, maine galti ki.”
How to Protect Yourself
Separate Insurance and Investment: Buy a term insurance plan with 10–20 times your annual income for proper coverage. Invest the rest in other options based on your risk appetite.
Ask Tough Questions: Demand clarity on all charges, premium allocation, mortality, fund management, and surrender fees. If the agent dodges, walk away.
Do Your Homework: Research independently. Check IRDAI’s website or consult a SEBI-registered advisor, not a commission-driven agent.
Avoid Emotional Pressure: Never buy a ULIP because your cousin or bank manager insists. It’s your money, not their target.
Check Tax Implications: If your ULIP premium exceeds ₹2.5 lakh annually, expect capital gains tax. Compare with other investment options for better transparency.
Test Your ULIP Knowledge!
Think you’ve got the ULIP game figured out? Answer this question for a chance to win a free one-hour consultation with a SEBI-registered financial advisor (details to claim will be shared with winners via your email, if you are a premium subscribedr:
Question: What’s the biggest red flag when an agent pitches a ULIP to you?
A) Promises of guaranteed returns
B) Low first-year commission
C) Short lock-in period of 1 year
D) Full transparency on all charges
Drop your answer in the comments. Five lucky winners will get expert advice to secure their financial future!
Join TheBrink’s premium subscription and stay ahead of the curve.
